Intuitive Japanese Calligraphic Ideogram Intuitive Systems: Leadership for the 21st Century: online strategies and communications

The Business Blog at Intuitive.com

Dave Taylor
Dave Taylor has been involved with the Internet since 1980 and is widely recognized as an expert on both technical and business issues. He has been published over a thousand times, launched four Internet-related startup companies, has written twenty business and technical books and holds both an MBA and MS Ed. Dave maintains four weblogs: The Business Blog at Intuitive.com, Ask Dave Taylor, Dave On Film, and Attachment Parenting Blog. Dave is an award-winning speaker, sought after conference and workshop participant and frequent guest on radio and podcast programs.

Mattel finally has the chance to axe the horrid Bratz line

I'm going to guess that there's a good chance you don't track the doll market, but there's been a very interesting intellectual property case that's been brewing for a few years, pitting toy colossus Mattel (NYSE: MAT) against upstart MGA Entertainment. The dueling dolls? Barbie versus Bratz.

I've actually written about this case before, on my parenting blog, muchly because I so loath the Bratz line and all it represents for young girls and its terrible impact on both their self-image and understanding of how their sexuality allows them to fail or succeed in modern society. See: Hey Mattel! Now you can put Bratz to sleep once and for all. (yeah, it's a bit biased)

After a few months of legal arguments and deliberations, let me quote the Wall Street Journal's report of the outcome:

"U.S. District Court in Riverside, Calif., essentially handed over MGA's pouty-lipped, hip-hop-themed Bratz franchise to Mattel, the maker of the iconic Barbie, whose sales have been undercut by the upstart Bratz in recent years. Judge Stephen G. Larson's ruling came several months after a federal jury found that the Bratz dolls were originally conceived by a designer who worked at Mattel and surreptitiously took the concept to MGA."
Of course MGA is complaining and saying that they'll appeal, but I mean, come on, guys, if you want to complain about fairness, then maybe you shouldn't have hired the Mattel toy designer and started manufacturing dolls that he designed while at Mattel.

Bratz doll line

I'm really pleased at this ruling and hope that Mattel either completely shut down the entire Bratz brand or, at a minimum, retool these dolls to be a bit less pouty sluts and a bit more cute young girls that actually don't reinforce all that's messed up about our cultural view of girls and sexuality.

This can be done through Mattel ultimately licensing the Bratz line to MGA and requiring that they make it a bit more wholesome or bringing the brand in-house, but either way, now's your golden moment, Mattel Brand President Neil Friedman. Do what's right for your brand, your corporate image, and the millions of girls who enjoy the Mattel doll lines as playthings.

Posted by Dave Taylor at December 5, 2008 10:05 AM

Comments

Don't count on them axing the Bratz any time soon. Now they can sell "wholesome" Barbies (formerly "impossible dimensions" Barbies) and "edgy" Bratz and have the entire market cornered. Although our girls like the Bratz, we are fortunate that they like Barbies even more. And we have been able to almost evade Bratz toys in our house...but not quite.

Posted by: David Leonhardt on December 5, 2008 10:30 AM

Hi Dave, your twitter post containing the words "Axe the entire Bratz line" caught my eye and I was compelled to read more. Could it be true I was hoping, with my fingers crossed so tight I've now got red knuckles :)

Glad to see someone else share my views about the drivel that's rammed down our kids throats everyday. Sadly both my daughter and my son like Bratz, even after my 2 hour lecture about the unrealistic lives the Bratz lead - my kids still like to watch it. So there you have it, my kids don't care what I think about Bratz and I've officially turned into my Dad - Blimey!

Flippin Kids TV - Cuh!

Cheers Dave, glad to know I'm not alone - there's still hope.

Posted by: Phill Mason on December 5, 2008 11:19 AM

The finding that hundreds of Bratz products infringed Mattel copyrights does not bode well for MGA. If nothing changes between now and February, MGA will have to recall the dolls and destroy the plates and molds.

The doll designer who invented the Bratz concept while under contract with Mattel, was found to have secretly sold it to MGA. This underscores the importance of having detailed employment and work-for-hire contracts that address intellectual property.

Posted by: David McCurley on December 5, 2008 3:43 PM

Nicely said about the fairness of this decision. People who are lamenting MGA's fate evidently don't understand that thieves have to return the property they stole when they are are caught.

Posted by: IL on December 5, 2008 3:56 PM

Mattel: Hey judge! There was a designer who presented an idea to us years ago that we turned down because we wanted to continue making product girls were buying less and less of. But another company used the idea and through innovation and hard work, created a succesful line out of it. We can't beat them fairly, so we'd like to sue them to death.
Judge: Great idea! And in this spiraling economy, thousands of people will lose their jobs at MGA!

They turned down the idea. They would have never used it.
Furthermore, designers do "moonlighting" for competing companies all the time. It may not be legal, but they do. Mattel is just as guilty of it. Believe me I know from personal experience.


Posted by: c on December 8, 2008 11:35 AM

As a mother of a son, I have not kept up with the other gender's attractions. My biggest concerns have been with the extreme violence of video gaming and online social networks that keep boys steamed up--the other kind of steaming comes easily enough when you walk through the "juniors" section of any department store. Those kind of clothes used to be for the lingerie biz--not 14 year olds.
How does any parent with both genders have the strength to battle double troubles? Too bad the court decision could not address the product itself...that looks to be a separate fight.

Posted by: Jay on December 11, 2008 1:51 PM

I couldn't agree more about the need to axe brats. I too, like an earlier commenter saw the title of the post and thought "Please God, let this be true!". You can be sure that Mattel will not kill bratz. It goes against the entire psychopathic ethos of corporate activity. Too much market share at stake. Someone just needs to start a blog called killthebratz.com and post regularly, with great vengeance!

Posted by: anon on December 17, 2008 7:59 AM

I doubt Mattel will kill the Bratz line... In reality it's up to the market. If overnight people grow some kind of moral code that says that selling sex to young people is more than a little creepy, it wouldn't be too long before Bratz would be gone. So to parents out there, stop buying Bratz dolls. Don't you know that by buying bratz dolls you are giving your child, your seal of approval, to dress and behave like that. Is that what you want... a pregnant 13-year old? Parents grow some cojones!

Posted by: Bill on December 28, 2008 5:02 PM

this is stupid i dnt no why people are calling bratz girls sluts barbie are the sluts they arnt role models if you see all the bratz dolls colection you will see that they arnt sluts
mattel should accept the fact that bratz are better than them or wrk together with mga so bratz will not get shut down!

PLEASE DONT CLOSE BRATZ DOWN THEY ARE THE BEST!

Posted by: DD on April 26, 2009 3:51 AM

Hi i think you should just take the dolls back,
then publish them as your own because lets be honest even 9 year olds play with them, but kids stop playing with barbies when thier 7 so what if there a bit wierd girls like the an awful lot more than barbies.

p.s.dont say its barbaric what ive said, but still just take a bit off the puffy lips if you do whatr my opinion says.

Posted by: liliao on May 26, 2009 4:15 AM
Insider's Guide to Blogging
Before you leave a comment, a tip: If you're interested in blogging, you should sign up for my Blogsmart News so you can stay up to date on the latest insider tips and ideas for your Internet business and marketing efforts. Sign up right now and you'll get a free copy of my "Insider's Guide to Blogging" ebook too!
 
Post a comment




Because I value your thoughtful opinions, I encourage you to add a comment to this discussion. Don't be offended if I edit your comments for clarity or to keep out questionable matters, however, and I may even delete off-topic comments.



RDF XML GeoURL Add to My Yahoo!

Valid CSS!